Sustainable Futures Podcast by Earth5R
Benno Werlen took a field trip to East Africa in 1977 and came back convinced that the way we map the world is part of the problem. Decades later he steered the International Year of Global Understanding through UNESCO and started the Jena Declaration.
He tells Earth5R founder Saurabh Gupta why change has to reach everyday routines, why the phrase “save the planet” misses the point, and why applied science should aim for authenticity rather than authority.
Prof. Benno Werlen
UNESCO Chair on Global Understanding for Sustainability, Friedrich Schiller University Jena
Saurabh Gupta
Founder and CEO, Earth5R, and host
Five ideas from this conversation
- Start from everyday life. If a change does not go into everyday routines, it will not be sustainable.
- Turn the logic upside down. Let the people inside a problem define it, then bring in science and engineering. Bottom up, or at least equal to top down.
- From culture to nature. Look at how culturally shaped lifestyles transform nature. We are part of nature, so we cannot save the planet, only ourselves.
- Redefine a successful life. Success cannot be linked to destruction. The humanities and the arts must create new images of a good life.
- Authenticity, not authority. Applied research should be measured by trust with everyday partners, not citations.
Chapter 01 of 07
From farm fields in East Africa to the International Year of Global Understanding
Watch from 0:00SGSaurabh Gupta
Welcome to the Sustainable Futures Podcast. Today, we are honoured to have Professor Benno Werlen with us.
Professor Werlen is a global leader in sustainability, holding a prestigious UNESCO Chair on Global Understanding for Sustainability. He is the founder and executive director of the International Year of Global Understanding and of the Jena Declaration, both of which have made significant strides in the field of sustainability.
His work has earned him numerous accolades, including the Outstanding Teacher’s Award from the University of Jena, the Lauréat d’honneur from the International Geographical Union for his lifelong contribution to geographical science, and a Best Practice Award from the European Commission. He has also been a distinguished guest at the American Association of Geographers’ annual conference in San Francisco.
It’s a privilege to have such an impactful figure in the world of sustainability with us. Professor Werlen, thank you so much for joining us today.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Thank you, Saurabh, for having me and for making me part of your project.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Professor Werlen, we’ll start with understanding a bit more about your work, the local action and global goals that you have been promoting. You have had a long career in the field of sustainability. What are some of the key moments that shaped your journey?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
You know, when you get older, the journey gets longer and longer.
When I did my studies in the 1970s, in the Cold War period, in Fribourg, Switzerland, I was also studying agricultural economics. Over several years, I followed presentations from representatives of the FAO and other UN organisations based in Geneva. Once a month, we had a presentation about the big problems humanity is facing.
It was the time of The Limits to Growth from the Club of Rome. That was an important text to discuss, and it was commented on by people from the organisations I just mentioned.
Then, in 1977, I was involved in a two month field trip to Africa. We visited Tanzania, Kenya, Rwanda and what was then called Zaire.
I was struck by the agriculture I could see there. I was thinking, gosh, if they had better instruments, and if they could be told how to put the different plants together, their orientation, the sunlight and so on, then with very little money agricultural production could be improved considerably.
When I came back, I wrote a dissertation in economics, more than 100 pages long, on the very humble question of whether ecological agriculture could solve the problems of nutrition in the world. I mean, whether it could overcome famine.
I did an internship of several weeks on an ecological farm run in the logic of the anthroposophical thinking of Rudolf Steiner. So I became familiar with ecological agriculture.
My conclusion was that it could work to solve the problem of famine in the world, just because it is not that capital intensive, and it could easily reach a lot of people without a big amount of money. It would work, but it needs a lot of institutional reforms.
And I was a little bit sceptical, because I learned that in Eastern Africa people did not call cars cars, they just called them Toyota. They were already very much taken into the global capitalist production system.
So I then wrote a dissertation on the critique of functionalism in geography and the social sciences. I became aware that the problems I saw in the ecological respect were very much linked to the geographical worldview established across the world.
People were thinking about spaces. They were talking about countries, they were talking about the Third World, and all this kind of vocabulary that I saw as totally inappropriate for the problems we are facing.
So with my PhD I first studied an alternative theoretical perspective for geography. The proposition was to change geography from an earth space science to a science of action.
Geography should not be categorising the world according to spatial categories or principles. The idea of geography should be to study scientifically how people make geography in their everyday life.
That means taking into account the way people themselves see the world, and not just telling them what to do without being interested in the way they are doing it. Or even categorising them as underprivileged or underdeveloped by spatial categories, the Third World, the Global South and so on.
Of course, this was not expected by the community of geographers worldwide. I remained rather an outsider with my concept, and I was very much contested. If you break the paradigm, you can’t hope that everybody likes you. That’s how the world is.
But then people from the international geographical community got interested in what I was doing. I was invited to take over a commission of the International Geographical Union called Cultural Approach in Geography.
Through that, I was invited to help conceptualise an international UN year on a geographical and cultural topic.
I was not satisfied with the first draft. I said, if you want me to continue to work on this, I want the possibility to present my own proposition. I did that, and I conceptualised the International Year of Global Understanding.
The idea is that people need to understand the ongoing globalisation. How much their everyday life in certain places is influenced or determined by global processes, and how local life is affecting the global level. So how people can do things to contribute to the solution of global problem constellations.
This was then accepted internally in the framework of geography. Then I presented it to all the presidents of the natural science organisations in Paris. If I remember correctly, there are 75 disciplines, from physics to biology and so on, with all their presidents and general secretaries.
I made them aware that what they see as the global challenges, as they called their project, is in fact determined by problematic human actions, especially since the Industrial Revolution. I showed them how changes in forms of production affect the global climate, and how different cultures and lifestyles affect different aspects of the physical world.
I was claiming that it is not scientifically sound to reduce the problems of humanity to natural science problems. We cannot just talk about the climate crisis and then ask politicians to solve the climate crisis.
You first have to understand in what cultural fields these problematic actions are embedded. So I brought in people from the social sciences and from the humanities.
In a certain form, I was combining the different scientific areas through the personal links I established among them with the International Year of Global Understanding. That took long negotiations and hundreds of meetings around the planet.
The idea of geography should be to study scientifically how people make geography in their everyday life.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Which year was this?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
I started that in 2008, and presented it to the scientific unions in March 2011.
The idea was to launch the international year in 2012. But the negotiations among the scientific unions were so slow.
Then the question was how to approach UNESCO. It was clear that if you want an international year on a scientific issue, it has to be supported by UNESCO. Otherwise it would never happen.
So I was looking for a supporting country, and that was a complicated issue. I was somehow involved in the role of a diplomat as a scientist, and that’s not the easiest task to take on.
Finally, I succeeded in finding Rwanda, which was ready, by decision of its government, to take the lead in that process. Then the African Union was ready to take it on, and it became part of the political agenda of the African Union.
Finally, I went through all levels of the decision making process of UNESCO, first to bring it to the Executive Board. It was really a remarkable moment in my lifetime to be present at the Executive Board meeting when my project was discussed and debated, and then passed without any changes. Later on, it was accepted by the General Conference of UNESCO.
Then it was ready to bring to New York. There I was talking, not to the official plenary assembly, but to the representatives of all countries in the second largest room.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Which year was that?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
That was 2013. In the meantime, we had given up the idea of 2012, because everything was slowed down. So the idea was to have it in 2016, because we needed a year between each decision, then one year of preparation and so on.
It was quite impressive. I had five minutes to present the project in the name of Rwanda, in front of all these representatives from the United States, Russia and the others. I was sitting next to the representative of Russia, because the countries are ordered alphabetically and Rwanda comes next to Russia. He was not very much interested in what I was talking about, but that was not important at that moment.
Then I talked to the UN ambassadors of each voting group. I was invited by Korea for Asia, by Mali for Africa, by Portugal for Europe and so on. I was quite optimistic that everything would work well, but in fact we didn’t get the UN year.
So in 2015, at the international social science summit in Durban, the International Year of Global Understanding was proclaimed jointly by the natural sciences and the social sciences.
That moment of my career has been very important for what I’m doing now. In fact, it was much bigger than many of the official UN international years, with far more than 1,000 events on global understanding across the planet in 2016.
Then the International Council for Philosophy and Human Sciences took on the idea of establishing five UNESCO chairs on global understanding around the world, and I was invited to hold one of them.
So I started the whole application process for the UNESCO chair. That’s quite complicated and it takes time, I guess two years all in all.
I was then nominated in 2018, for four years until 2022, and then for another four years until 2026. So that’s the trajectory, if you want.
Chapter 02 of 07
What a UNESCO Chair does, and why science is not reaching everyday life
Watch from 17:07SGSaurabh Gupta
That gives us quite an idea. You had to go through several rounds of negotiations, presentations and amendments.
A lot of our readers come from very diverse backgrounds. They are always looking to understand how, if they have an idea, they could take it through institutions like the United Nations, or into policy design. So this is very helpful.
Coming to the next question, on global sustainability and innovation from the UNESCO chair perspective. Could you explain how the UNESCO chair supports new ideas and research in sustainability, and what kind of impact they have globally?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
What people very often have difficulty understanding is that they think UNESCO chairs are paid by UNESCO. That’s not true.
UNESCO chairs are applied for through the National Commission for UNESCO, and you have to show that the university is able to sponsor the chair. UNESCO wants to make sure that the university or country applying gives the chair the financial and personnel background to function.
So you have to prove that you have the money, and you don’t get any money from UNESCO. You have to prove that you have the capacity to handle it.
The second important point, and that explains what a UNESCO chair in fact is, is that you have to show how much the programme of the chair can contribute to fulfilling the programmes of UNESCO and the UN. Of course you need a scientific standing, otherwise you wouldn’t be a professor.
That shows how the structure is. The professors are not there to suggest programmes for UNESCO and the UN. It’s rather the other way around.
The general conferences, or the plenary assembly of the UN, are making or accepting the programmes. The professors are there to help the institution reach its goals.
So the professors are not the agenda setters. The administrations and the national representations to UNESCO and the UN are setting the agenda together with their staff. Of course you can contribute, as we do, on the basis of my scientific programme or approach.
What makes such a position attractive, I think, is that you are one of nearly 950 UNESCO chairs globally. You are part of a network of UNESCO chairs and you can interact with them.
When they are close to your topic, you can collaborate with them, and you have a framework for collaboration that you wouldn’t have otherwise. There are also the so called UNITWIN networks, several hundreds of them, with a topical orientation.
You can address them if you want to have something discussed. If you organise a conference, you can invite them, collaborate with them and contribute to their activities.
With a UNESCO chair, you have a huge network set up by the institutions of the UN. So you can potentially have a big impact on international policies, which you never would have if you just stayed at the national level. That’s the point that is important to know.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Do you have examples of particular projects the UNESCO chair has taken up in terms of sustainability?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
UNESCO has three fields of action, and all three are now combined with the sustainability agenda of the UN, the SDGs. Those three fields are education, science and culture.
I try to combine the three in global understanding. Understanding is a concept of the humanities and of part of the social sciences, and it links to the cultural sphere, because culture is about meaning, communication and the production and understanding of meaning.
The scientific part is the social science part. But in the German context, due to Humboldt, geography is located in the natural science faculties. I’m a member of the Faculty of Chemistry and Earth Sciences, so institutionally I also have access to the natural sciences.
As for examples, at the local and national level I am involved in a project with a colleague from nearby Weimar on intangible cultural heritage, the organ. This instrument is very important in religious music all over Europe and even beyond.
We are looking at how the establishment of an organ in small communities forges some kind of solidarity, and how it reproduces the community through religious celebrations, but also as a musical and cultural instrument. So we have culture, the social sciences and the human sciences related.
I was also involved in a UNESCO book production on the future of education. On that basis, I was finally invited to represent the European UNESCO chairs in a project of the Canadian Commission for UNESCO and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada on the production of future knowledge. How should we produce knowledge for social transformation?
SGSaurabh Gupta
Oh, interesting.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
The project I submitted was to interview a number of leaders of UN and UNESCO programmes in sustainability and the ecological domain, like Man and the Biosphere.
Also leaders in the social sciences and humanities, presidents of different scientific unions and international organisations, and several academies, like the International Science Council and the Academia Europaea.
The main question we were asking them was why they believe we are missing the reach of the Agenda 2030 in time. This despite the long lasting engagement of the UN in sustainability issues since the early 1970s, with Man and the Biosphere starting at the end of the 1960s, if I remember correctly.
A lot of money has been invested, also in technology, and we are not moving forward. What is the reason for that?
That was quite interesting. Each interview lasted one to two hours. We recorded them, transcribed them, and sent the transcript and our conclusions back so they could check and revise them if they wanted. Then we wrote the paper for the publication of the Canadian Commission and the research council I mentioned.
Part of the project was also to discuss the results with some of the people who took part in the survey and others in the field. We had an online conference with about 30 people from different areas of engagement and different versions of sustainability, discussing the measures needed to speed up social transformation.
The key outcome was that the scientific approach is partly responsible for not reaching the most important agents of societal transformation. These are everyday people around the planet, with their everyday routines.
If a change does not go into the everyday routine, the change will not be sustainable.
So that was the outcome. If you accept that, then one of the reasons we are not moving forward faster is the dominance of the natural sciences in the whole discourse. Normal everyday people are not scientists. They are not familiar with the scientific language and concepts of the experts in the geosciences, geotechnology and so on.
So the question is, how do you build the bridge between scientific knowledge, scientific insights, everyday practices and their transformative potential to solve global problem constellations?
Another outcome of the survey was that, for global problem constellations, education is absolutely not sufficient anymore. We have a high specialisation in disciplines, and school curricula to a certain extent mirror scientific research.
We have natural science disciplines, some humanities like literature, and a little bit of political education. But everything is specialised. It’s like a training camp for future scientists, and it’s not a training camp for problem solving.
In the phrasing of the people of the Club of Rome, we need to overcome the silos of school knowledge.
If a change does not go into the everyday routine, the change will not be sustainable.
SGSaurabh Gupta
We also need to make the information more digestible.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Yes. So the point is how to reach people.
The point that follows is that interdisciplinarity is not a solution for global problem constellations, for many reasons. First of all, the data are all national and collected with different categorisations and parameters. You cannot aggregate them soundly.
So we have global problem constellations and national solutions. It’s like politics. You only have a national discourse to solve global problems.
If you take that seriously, you have to change the educational system from primary school up to university, and the whole knowledge production. As I said from the beginning, you need to take into account the cultural context of everyone living on this planet.
If you want a respectful way to get in touch with someone, you have to accept the cultural context the other person is in, as much as you expect people to respect your own. If you accept that, then the idea of solving global problems only through agreements at international gatherings of the UN is absurd.
If governments find an agreement that can be accepted by at least the majority of countries, how do you transmit it into different cultural realms? It’s a natural science solution and a diplomatic agreement, but it is not prepared for people to implement.
So you have to turn the whole thing upside down. You have to start working with communities with a transdisciplinary attitude, asking them how they see the problem, and looking at whether there are solutions in their cultural and regional context and how people deal with that kind of problem.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Yes, a lot of solutions. One example is the Earth5R app, where we launched challenges for people to share stories of their traditional ways of sustainability. In India, for example, there is the practice of cooking in clay pots, a very local, low carbon and natural solution that is good for health.
People have been sharing a lot of stories, and that gives us a lot of ideas about how sustainability is practised in different cultures. You can find a lot of common ground, but sometimes you have to respect that sustainability also has to be local.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Exactly. You have to find a local solution for local problems, but based on proven facts and proven natural science insights.
Turning things upside down means the problem is defined by the people involved in it, the people who are part of the problem situation.
Then social scientists, cultural anthropologists, geographers and others who have cultural sensitivity and are familiar with the local culture look for other knowledge that could help, from the natural sciences, from engineering, from other sectors. They get in touch with them and ask, what would you do to solve this problem there?
If you accept that, you have to conclude that international agreements are not the perfect way to solve global problems. It’s a possible way, but it’s not sufficient.
Interdisciplinarity is not helpful either, because everybody stays in their silo looking for connections between scientific disciplines, but not with the agents who should apply that knowledge. So you need a transdisciplinary approach, and consequently a paradigm change of all sustainability policies, from a top down logic to a bottom up logic.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Exactly.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Or at least to have both at the same level of competence and reach.
That was the outcome of the conference. We discussed it, and people added more to the results of the survey. Then we reached the question, what are we doing with these insights?
I said, we could have a kind of manifesto of this event, or maybe a declaration. People got quite enthusiastic about the idea of a declaration, and I was asked to put some text together. I did that with a couple of other participants in the conference, and we called it the Jena Declaration.
Chapter 03 of 07
The Jena Declaration: from top down to bottom up
Watch from 36:49SGSaurabh Gupta
I was coming to that question. Your Jena Declaration is very interesting in terms of regional and cultural sustainability, and it’s a very important piece of work in which you have played a key role. I’d like to know more about what exactly it is and how it addresses global sustainability challenges.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
It is called the Jena Declaration because the UNESCO chair at the University of Jena organised the survey and the conference. But it is also symbolic, because the historical heritage of Jena has all the ingredients of the declaration.
Jena is the place where modern ecology was coined, by Ernst Haeckel. Hans Carl von Carlowitz, a member of the Alma Mater Jenensis, used the term sustainability for the first time in 1713, in the way it is used now in UN and UNESCO programmes and the Agenda 2030.
And we had a movement starting from here, the Romantic movement, which had the idea of combining the natural sciences and the humanities, to have a view of nature that is not emptied of any meaning, to put it that way.
So we have all three parts that are in question. Sustainability itself, the ecological turn in the phrasing of the UN and UNESCO, and the counter movement that was addressed by the Romantic movement. All three are linked to Jena, so the Jena Declaration is a wonderful name for the ingredients of the declaration.
In telling you about the conference and its results, I have already given the main lines of the Jena Declaration. To put it roughly, the Jena Declaration calls for a double shift of paradigm in sustainability research and sustainability policies.
First, changing the logic, as I already said, from top down to bottom up.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Yes.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
That means a solid integration of citizens’ views and citizen engagement in the sustainable transformation of societies. And always in line with cultural backgrounds, compatible with the way people live.
You can’t change everybody’s way of life in one lifetime. That’s impossible. So we have to find solutions within our lifetime for better adaptations.
The second shift is not from nature to culture, but from culture to nature. We look at how nature is transformed by culturally shaped lifestyles, and with knowledge of those lifestyles we look for new, less problematic forms of transforming our natural background.
The third important point is that the Jena Declaration does not talk about the natural environment, because with our bodies we are part of nature. Nature is our co-world, in German Mitwelt, and not Umwelt, not environment.
Everything we do for healthy natural conditions, we do for ourselves at the same time. We don’t do it for the environment. We do it for us, and for the species.
It’s about us, and not the planet. It’s about life forms on the planet. So we should also get rid of the phrase “save the planet”. That’s quite ridiculous. We are not able to save the planet.
SGSaurabh Gupta
That’s very egoistic.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
The planet existed before humans arrived, and it will be there when humans disappear, so that can’t be the point. At most, we can save humans. We can save ourselves.
We are not able to save the planet. At most, we can save humans. We can save ourselves.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Yes.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
The planet is always going to be there. In fact, it’s about looking for healthy living conditions for all life forms.
SGSaurabh Gupta
For all life forms, that’s true.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
It is then also about education, restructuring the whole idea of education and changing the focus from educating to learning, learning from one another.
Everyday people can learn from the scientific stock of knowledge, but scientists can also learn from the local stock of knowledge. How solutions worked or didn’t work in earlier times, and so on.
These are a couple of points that are central to the logic of the Jena Declaration. Taken all together, the conclusion is to make better use of the insights of the humanities and the social sciences, especially the cultural aspects.
The problem, in my experience, is that the humanities and social sciences are by far not as well organised as the natural sciences. They have maybe only a few percent of the budgets of the natural science and engineering organisations. That makes them, in principle, very weak in the debates on how sustainability should be addressed.
That’s why I think the arts need to play a stronger role in sustainability, because the arts are creators of mindsets.
SGSaurabh Gupta
That’s true. Behaviours.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
They make people see the world in specific ways. So the arts, together with some scientific disciplines, are the key drivers of worldviews.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Like you just said, we can’t save the world. That’s a shift of perspective.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Of course, artists have very often created their own world somehow. By definition they can’t be organised like natural scientists, who need laboratories and so on.
But still, we need to mobilise artists, not just to mirror or illustrate the vocabulary and concepts of the geosciences, not just reproducing the Agenda 2030, but to open new directions for new lifestyles.
One of the points embedded in the logic of the Jena Declaration is that we need to change the definition of a successful life. So far, success is mirrored by the amount of resources somebody can consume. 100 cars, 80 bathrooms and so on. That’s wealth, that’s material success.
We need to make clear that this is not success. It is the opposite of success in the sense of creating healthy conditions for everyone.
SGSaurabh Gupta
It’s just the opposite.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Success can’t be linked to destruction. Today, success is mirrored by destructive ways of dealing with our natural basis and living conditions.
Having a jet for every meeting, two people flying over the Atlantic or the Pacific to meet someone at the other end of the world. Of course, that’s a kind of freedom, but we also need to change the idea of freedom in that respect if we want a sustainable world.
There you can see that the humanities, the cultural sciences and the arts need to produce new images of the world, and new images of a good life.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Apart from the agenda in the Jena Declaration, how do you want to implement it? Is there a plan?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Yes. A plan that has not been very successful so far, I have to admit.
The idea was to gather a huge body of signatories, thousands and thousands of people signing the Jena Declaration, so that we could approach the UN or UNESCO and say, look, we have so many citizens who are really looking for a change of paradigm. But this is very complicated, and that was also part of our survey.
We are in a world where echo chambers are growing and becoming more and more important. People only want to hear what they think anyway, and whether it’s based on empirical facts or on so called alternative truths is very often not important.
This makes people very cautious with digital devices, like signing a declaration on an internet platform without knowing the people behind it. So the summary after nearly two years of implementation is that we haven’t been able to combine the analogue everyday world with signing on a digital platform in a way that has an impact.
We now have a solution, or hope to have one, but it’s too early to talk about. The idea, as I said, is to gather a large number of project partners, institutional supporters and signatories.
We now have a little more than 40 project partners across the world, all in different countries. We have more than 200 institutional signatories, some with hundreds of thousands of members, and then about a thousand individual signatories. But this is not the size we are looking for.
So the idea is to overcome the gap between the analogue world and digital signatures. I can tell you the idea, but we have to test it first.
For each institutional partner and each project partner, we have people we are familiar with, through exchanges on Zoom and at on-site conferences. They would be our partners of trust.
People would sign the Jena Declaration on site in the presence of that person of trust, who hands it over to us, and we fill it in on the platform. We will communicate through our partners of trust with the communities on the other end, like your organisation, hopefully very soon as well.
That’s how we can grow. Some partners are large, like yours with 700,000 participants. If we can combine them, maybe we can have an impact on the institutional realities of science and of sustainability policies, and start a movement of peaceful transformation.
That’s the most important idea. If you force people to change their way of life, it can never be sustainable.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Yes, it’s not sustainable.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
It never has been, and it never will be. People need incentives to change.
I have a new phrasing for the idea of the Jena Declaration, living sustainably with joy and engagement. People should gain something when they change, and be able to express themselves. That would make it more attractive to engage.
In scientific logic, in disciplinary research, we are looking for authority. You become a master of knowledge in your field. That’s the goal of a scientific career, becoming an authority.
But for applied science this can’t be the goal, to have as many citations as someone doing basic research, or as much project money. The aim of applied science can’t be scientific success, but it can be authenticity.
Authenticity is the idea of the good person in applied research, who is trusted by partners in the everyday world and is a good mediator between science and the everyday world. So being authentic would be the claim, and not authority.
Living sustainably with joy and engagement.
SGSaurabh Gupta
That’s right. One example is a module in the Earth5R app for people who are concerned about air quality in their area. They walk for a kilometre with their mobile phone, which geotags the route, so first of all they are walking rather than using a car.
They count the trees in their locality, and that data goes into public spaces. We have measured hundreds of thousands of kilometres across the country, so we know the tree density on each stretch of a particular city.
Then citizens know they are falling short of trees in their area, and they go for plantation programmes. The input builds an output that pushes them to plant more, because they understand they need more trees for better air quality. So the data is an incentive. It helps them understand the gaps, and then they fill those gaps.
Chapter 04 of 07
Knowledge mobilisation and living labs
Watch from 55:17SGSaurabh Gupta
Through your work on the Jena Declaration, you also dived into the concept of knowledge mobilisation. Could you explain it a bit more for the audience?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
I already described it. It means engaging with citizens in their everyday world, mobilising knowledge production adapted to local conditions and cultural contexts. These are new forms of knowledge production.
A subsequent idea is to set up living labs as learning models and not as educational models. Children and young people can experience certain conditions and the difficulties in them, and then look for solutions, knowing that there is an abstract way to deal with it but also a concrete level of implementation.
This process of knowledge production and knowledge application would be part of learning at all levels, what is traditionally called education. At primary school, with simpler conditions in the direct local context, and then, with age, more complex situations. That’s knowledge mobilisation through practice, in practical situations.
This is not against scientific ways of dealing with reality at all. We need a disciplinary way of knowledge production.
But less than 1% of children in primary school will end up in science or a scientific enterprise. I don’t know exactly, but certainly not more than 1%. So why do we bother the other 99% with a logic in which they will never succeed, and can’t succeed, because other people also have to do things other than research?
If you take that into account, and if you agree on that, then we really need to change schooling at all levels.
A member of the Jena Declaration, Howard Blumenthal, has the project Kids on Earth. He has been interviewing kids around the world for many years about how they see the world.
Of course, these are kids who have digital devices, so that’s a certain selection. But they all say that what they learn at school has less and less to do with the lives they are living on this planet.
Its logic is from the 19th century, and we are now in the 21st century. It would be a miracle if everything were still adapted to today’s living conditions.
We need to take into account how people live today, and how job markets are changing radically every few decades or even faster. We cannot keep models of education from a time when the job market stayed more or less the same for half a century.
We have to rethink all these things. I hope we can contribute a little to opening our minds in that direction, and to reach a knowledge production and adoption that helps create globally sustainable conditions for everyone.
Chapter 05 of 07
What governments and institutions can do
Watch from 60:20SGSaurabh Gupta
Professor Werlen, let’s discuss institutional challenges in global sustainability. What can governments and institutions do to create more effective sustainability strategies and initiatives? Effective is the key here.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
If you more or less accept what I just presented, then in my experience governments need to learn a more respectful way of dealing with their citizens. They need to take citizens’ views and problem definitions seriously, and not start from the idea that the ministry knows everything better than any citizen in the country.
That means a more democratic exchange between governors and the governed. We need collaboration and exchange, but a total top down logic of knowledge adaptation is not really democratic.
SGSaurabh Gupta
That’s true.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
It gives power to a certain group. We saw that during the COVID-19 pandemic, when natural scientists and people from medicine tried to make social policy. That’s very often not very helpful.
Of course, we all depend on the knowledge of medical research. But the way it’s applied should be more open. Governments should prepare scenarios for how to act in an emergency, and not be lost when there is one.
They should be prepared for all the forms of emergencies that will probably arise at a faster rhythm than we can think of today. They also need to rethink the way they deal with problem situations inside their territory, and in a global perspective where possible.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Are there any frameworks you can suggest? As you said, governments should not see themselves as experts who know everything. It’s very important to have citizens involved, with a more inclusive approach rather than a top down approach. Are there any frameworks you would suggest, based on your experience?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
We are working on that, but the financial means don’t allow us to implement it yet.
The idea is to establish a digital platform where people with similar problems from different parts of the world can exchange, free of charge, with free access. They can discuss things, and the owner of the platform would organise forms of translation.
We all have a body, and our bodies are not so completely different across the planet as some people pretend. So many problems are similar.
We can look for solutions, considering the specific conditions of human bodies and the bodies of other living life forms. We can discuss solutions, and see the impact of local solutions at the global level and the other way around.
The point is to make people understand that we depend on one another more than ever before in human history. The impact of our transformation of nature is so strong in the so called Anthropocene.
Not so long ago, with a third of today’s world population, if somebody had a fire somewhere in the world, it didn’t really matter.
But now we have nuclear power stations and other highly transformative installations, means of transport, the way we build our houses and so on. With a growing world population, the impact of local action on the global level will grow, because the transformations are stronger and more numerous.
We are very connected now, and there is no escape. There is no other planet, we can forget about that. So we have to take our destiny into our own hands.
We cannot just trust governments, and we cannot think it’s sufficient to blame governments for not doing enough or doing the wrong things. We have to take action ourselves and not just blame others.
Saying that governments are not doing this and that, and therefore taking an action that makes everybody nervous, will not be the solution to our problems, I guess.
SGSaurabh Gupta
Yes, correct.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Every point on this planet is exposed to global processes.
There is no other planet, we can forget about that. So we have to take our destiny into our own hands.
Chapter 06 of 07
Advice for future sustainability professionals
Watch from 66:51SGSaurabh Gupta
In terms of guidance for future sustainability professionals, a lot of our readers, viewers and audience come from industry and are switching into sustainability or planning to. We also have a huge youth audience, college students who want jobs where they can make an impact and make the world a better place.
They come from very diverse academic backgrounds and sectors, and they want more meaningful careers with applied sustainability. What advice would you give them, what skills could they learn, and what should they do to build a career in sustainability?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
I’m thinking about this against the background of my experience. It’s a long one and not a very narrow one, but still very selective, like all experiences.
There are so many platforms around where people can connect with people with similar ideas around the planet. You know, I’m somehow too old to tell young people how they should organise their lives, because life conditions are changing so fast.
I would advise them to get in touch with people who have similar questions, discuss them, and find solutions together that are adapted to their background and their vision. There are so many people around the planet who have exactly the ambition you just mentioned.
Maybe we should put these kinds of platforms together and make them visible, people like you or me and others. Everyone is responsible for his or her own life. What we can do is offer them potentials, and they have to choose and take responsibility for the decision.
It’s very difficult for a person of my age to tell somebody who is 20 or 21, coming from India or Australia or Latin America, what the best way of planning a life is. That’s ridiculous. I can’t be the adviser for that, it’s impossible. But they could get in touch with people of their generation and look for their future together, because it will be a common destiny of their generation.
I’m somehow too old to tell young people how they should organise their lives, because life conditions are changing so fast.
SGSaurabh Gupta
So what you are suggesting is that they should connect with more people and talk to more people.
BWProf. Benno Werlen
Yes, and we could try to organise such an information platform where they can check possibilities and get in touch.
There’s an organisation called Catalyst 2030, I think, with tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people engaged in different projects. They are well organised, with chapters for Europe, Latin America, different parts of Asia and so on. There are many things around that are well done and really, really good.
That’s also a little bit the idea of the Jena Declaration, to bring such people together in a framework that can combine different forms. Then, with a snowball effect, we can maybe produce something very meaningful and encompassing in a short time.
Chapter 07 of 07
Global understanding, looking back
Watch from 71:10SGSaurabh Gupta
One last question, Professor. Could you explain what the UNESCO resolution on the International Year of Global Understanding, IYGU, is about, and what its main goals are?
BWProf. Benno Werlen
That’s exactly what I said before. Looking back, some people felt it should have a different phrasing, but I wanted to keep it open as global understanding.
Maybe it would have been better to call it understanding the global condition, because global understanding also has the side meaning of being nice to one another, being understanding.
The idea was to make people aware of the global impact of their own lives. How much they are embedded in global processes, and what the global consequences of their ways of living are.
We wanted to produce seven booklets as an introduction, stimulating this kind of thinking, but we only managed to produce three. One is about eating, drinking and surviving, how the way nutrition is organised has an impact on many people. That’s very well done.
The second is about working, housing and urbanisation, how the way we produce has an impact on the way we live and organise ourselves spatially. The last one is about communicating and interacting on a global scale.
The others haven’t been produced because the time was too short and the money too limited, and we were not able to replace certain people on the editorial boards. Maybe we should. The idea is ongoing, but it’s rather loosely organised at the moment.
The Jena Declaration is somehow the follow up to the International Year of Global Understanding. The resolution, which you can find in the UNESCO documents, focuses on integrating the sciences to engage together in global solutions for global problems.
One outcome is the International Science Council, where the social sciences and the natural sciences came together in one council. Its founding people were all involved in the International Year of Global Understanding, like Heide Hackmann and Gordon McBean. So that was one of the outcomes, continuing in that spirit under another name.
The idea, as I said, is to understand living conditions, and to see that cultural and social backgrounds shape ways of living. Natural scientists shouldn’t forget that there is always a cultural background. You can’t just pass a law based on social measurements and expect everybody to follow it. That will never work, so you have to be respectful in dealing with these issues.
In fact, the idea is also to produce a new geographical vision of the world, because our lives have changed. The world is no longer as it was when geography was established as a discipline of colonial powers, forging nationalism and serving as a national institution in schools.
We need another geographical representation of the world that better fits the way we live today. I think that’s important.
We need another geographical representation of the world that better fits the way we live today.
SGSaurabh Gupta
That’s a very interesting and fresh perspective.
Professor Werlen, it has been amazing to learn about your UNESCO journey and how the Jena Declaration evolved, starting from your field trip in Africa to where you are today. It’s a very big step that you have taken with the declaration.
At Earth5R, we would like to encourage our community members to look it up and sign it, and we’ll make it available on our website, in this blog and in our podcast. Thank you so much. Today we learned a lot about the art that goes into sustainability, apart from the science, and especially about geography. Thank you very much.
